
At their first German roadworthiness inspection, 18.5% of Tesla Model Ys had significant or dangerous defects, Der Spiegel reported, citing the new TÜV report. That put the Model Y last among two- to three-year-old cars, at nearly three times the average of 6.4%. Four electric cars in the same age group ranked among the ten models with the lowest defect rates.
The TÜV Association released the results on November 18. The report covered 9.7 million vehicles across 200 models, with a defect rate of 20.9% across all ages. For a Model Y at its first inspection, the more useful benchmark is cars of the same age. Against that group, the Model Y’s rate was 12.1 percentage points higher.
Suspension problems stood out on the Model Y. Joachim Bühler, the association’s managing director, pointed to the load that heavy batteries place on the suspension. The 18.5% figure covers all significant or dangerous defects, not just those involving the suspension.
The electric Mazda MX-30 e-Skyactiv offers a comparison for used-car buyers. Only two models its age had lower defect rates: the combustion-engine Mazda CX-60 and Mercedes-Benz GLA. For someone weighing up a recent used car, the inspection record of the particular model says more than whether it runs on electricity.
Sources
- Der Spiegel · Source date: 2026-11-18
Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-18