Skip to content
wua. Romania
English

Ryabkov rejects Article 5-style guarantees for Ukraine, contradicting Kushner’s account

A man gestures beside a microphone on the left, while a bespectacled man looks toward him across a sweeping blue-and-yellow flag.
AI illustration · WUA

Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov rejected an Article 5-style security guarantee for Ukraine on Friday, November 20, saying Moscow would not accept what he called “quasi-membership” of NATO. A day earlier in Berlin, US negotiator Jared Kushner had said he believed he and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff had persuaded Russia to accept that very principle.

Under Article 5, NATO allies regard an attack on one member as an attack on all. Kushner invoked the clause as a model for a guarantee to Ukraine, not as a treaty provision that already covers it. According to HotNews, he said he believed President Donald Trump was open to the idea, but that such a commitment would have to serve US interests.

Asked specifically about an Article 5-style guarantee, Ryabkov said Moscow approached the talks first and foremost from the standpoint of Russia’s own security. In remarks quoted by Interfax and reported by Reuters, whose account was carried by HotNews and Digi24, he said Ukraine must first acknowledge that Russia will not withdraw its demand that the country stay out of NATO. Only then, he said, could guarantees be discussed.

At the Berlin summit, which Romanian President Nicușor Dan also attended, French President Emmanuel Macron called for Ukraine’s NATO membership to be put back on the agenda. Ryabkov’s response matters even if Ukraine stays outside the alliance: he publicly rejected the model of protection that Kushner thought Moscow had accepted. Neither man described concrete obligations that any country had undertaken.

Sources

Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-20