
Joanne Young and her daughter Alex want the law changed so that defendants in rape trials like hers cannot rely on a partner’s word to argue that they believed the other person consented. The Sexual Offences Act 2003 already requires the person concerned to have the freedom and capacity to choose. The family’s challenge is about what a defendant can say they believed, not whether a husband has the right to consent for his wife.
Four men were convicted of sexual offences against Young at Winchester Crown Court on 19 November, two of them of rape. According to the BBC, her husband Philip had drugged and abused her over 13 years and used websites and apps to invite men to their Swindon home without her knowledge. The defendants said he had deceived them into believing she agreed. Prosecutors said none had sought her consent.
The convictions matter to the case for reform: the men were able to make that argument, but it did not secure their acquittal. What Philip Young told them could explain why they said they believed his wife had agreed. It could not establish that she had made that choice. That distinction ought to guide any change in the law.
Speaking outside court, Joanne Young urged the government to act: “No-one should be able to give it on your behalf.” Alex Young’s objection, set out in a LinkedIn post, was that a partner’s assurance could be used as an argument in court at all. The family has identified the argument it wants ruled out; the BBC report gives no proposed wording for how a court would draw that line.
Sources
- BBC UK · Source date: 2026-11-20
Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-20