Skip to content
wua. United Kingdom English

Joshua Thomas case: Peter Hindmarsh advised that help was needed earlier after hospital barred him from treating children with diabetes

A folded sheet partly conceals an insulin pen on the left, while a fountain pen rests on the open page to the right.
AI illustration · WUA

Prof Peter Hindmarsh told prosecutors that 12-year-old Joshua Thomas’s symptoms should have prompted his parents to seek medical help sooner. When he wrote that opinion in August 2023, his hospital had already barred him from treating children with diabetes on safety grounds, the Guardian reported on 21 November.

The prosecution turned on what Damion and Tamara Thomas could reasonably have recognised on the morning of 9 December 2022. Joshua was awake at 4am and went back to bed. Tamara called an ambulance at 12.33pm. He died the next day in Birmingham after developing severe diabetic ketoacidosis, a complication caused by a severe lack of insulin. This was his first episode of diabetes.

Hindmarsh judged that the signs described at 4am warranted a medical assessment. He did not specify that the parents should have called an ambulance at that hour. His opinion nevertheless supported the prosecution’s argument that they had waited too long.

University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust had excluded Hindmarsh from clinical practice in March 2023. Its concerns included the safety of his insulin advice to children. That overlap matters: the prosecution relied on his judgement about childhood diabetes, the very specialty in which the hospital had identified a risk. The restriction itself does not settle whether his assessment of Joshua’s symptoms was medically sound.

The couple’s elder son, Alessandro, told the Guardian the family had been unaware of the restriction and of a General Medical Council investigation. Hindmarsh declined to answer the newspaper’s questions about the restriction or when he disclosed it to police.

In March 2026, Tamara was convicted of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect. Damion was acquitted of manslaughter but convicted of neglect. Both maintain their innocence and have applied to the Court of Appeal for permission to challenge their convictions.

Sources

Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-21