Skip to content
wua. United Kingdom English

Ed Miliband and Rosebank: why he says he will not resign over a decision he will not make

AI-generated editorial illustration; this is not a photograph of the event.
Produced by wua.life

Ed Miliband has said he would not resign if the government approves the Rosebank oil field, placing collective responsibility ahead of his earlier public opposition to the project. His statement does not signal that Rosebank will be approved. The decision is still to be made by Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh.

Speaking to BBC Radio 4's Today programme, the foreign secretary said he would “definitely not” quit if Rosebank goes ahead because ministers must publicly support government decisions. He said Fahnbulleh would consider the evidence in what he described as a quasi-judicial process, and that he would not second-guess her conclusion.

That distinction matters. Rosebank is Britain's largest untapped oil field, off Shetland, but the current government is not simply choosing whether to repeat a settled policy. The previous Conservative government licensed the project in 2023, then the Court of Session in Edinburgh ruled last year that the approval had been made unlawfully. Labour must now take a new decision.

Miliband's position exposes the political consequence of that process rather than its outcome. In opposition, he called Rosebank a “colossal waste of taxpayer money and climate vandalism”. As a cabinet minister, he is now saying that a decision by the responsible energy secretary would bind him publicly even if it conflicted with that earlier view.

The argument around the field remains sharply divided. Labour MP Catherine Fookes told the BBC that further North Sea drilling would worsen climate change. Conservative shadow energy secretary Andrew Bowie argued that Britain needs more drilling and accused Labour of undermining North Sea investment. Labour MP Steve Yemm framed Rosebank as a test of whether investment and skilled North Sea work can coexist with climate obligations.

Neither case settles the immediate question of household energy bills. The BBC notes that oil prices are set on international markets, so extra supply offers no guarantee of cheaper UK bills. The next substantive development is Fahnbulleh's decision, which will determine whether Rosebank receives fresh approval after the earlier licence was struck down.

Sources

Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-16