
Aberdeen Royal Infirmary surgeon Dr Mohammed Habib called on Thursday for a corporate homicide investigation into NHS Grampian, disclosing two external reviews of surgical care. According to the BBC, the 2022 review examined 45 patients treated by the hospital’s liver and pancreatic services: 31 died, and reviewers judged 19 of those deaths avoidable. The later review advised that the hospital should not undertake complex or major liver, pancreatic or bile duct surgery because it lacked the specialist staff to provide the service safely.
The first review covered cases from 2015 to 2021. Its finding on avoidable deaths applies to the cases examined, not to all patients who used the services. Reviewers found that some liver operations went ahead even when surgeons thought the disease was inoperable. In pancreatic surgery, they found that patients regularly went to theatre without enough planning or consideration of alternatives. They also criticised the extent of blood loss during both types of surgery.
The second review, completed earlier in 2026, acknowledged NHS Grampian’s efforts to improve outcomes. But its authors found that problems with surgical decisions and severe blood loss had recurred, and that the board had not made the structural changes needed. Their recommendation concerned which operations Aberdeen should perform; it was not a decision to withdraw the service.
Habib said he formally raised concerns in 2021 and reported 20 cases to Police Scotland in 2024. No charges followed that referral. His call on 19 November asks for a criminal investigation into the board’s conduct. NHS Grampian management had not responded to his latest public allegations when the BBC reported.
Sources
- BBC UK · Source date: 2026-11-19
Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-19