Skip to content
wua. United Kingdom English

St Mellons crash: What the Gwent Police misconduct hearing is examining

AI-generated editorial illustration; this is not a photograph of the event.
Produced by wua.life

The Gwent Police misconduct hearing is examining a narrow but serious question: whether two officers truthfully carried out and recorded basic missing-person enquiries before the 2023 St Mellons crash was found.

PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone are accused of falsely claiming that searches had been conducted at the homes of Eve Smith and Sophie Russon. A car carrying five people was found crashed in woodland in St Mellons, Cardiff, two days after it left the road; Smith, Darcy Ross and Rafel Jeanne died.

According to the BBC's report from the Newport hearing, the officers were assigned to visit the homes, speak to relatives and search the properties as part of the missing-person investigation. The force's professional standards case alleges that records saying searches had taken place, and an update to a supervising officer, were dishonest. Family statements said no searches occurred at the two addresses concerned.

Hardwick and Livingstone, both still serving with Gwent Police, deny every allegation. Livingstone previously told the police watchdog that she had not knowingly been untruthful, while saying she could not remember whether searches had happened because of the passage of time. The panel, not the BBC report or this article, must decide whose evidence it accepts.

That distinction matters. The hearing is not deciding responsibility for the crash, and the force's case reportedly accepts that the alleged failures may not have changed the outcome for those in the car. But the alleged conduct still goes to a basic duty in a missing-person inquiry: officers must carry out assigned checks and make records that supervisors and families can rely on.

Police work cannot be judged only by whether a failure can be tied to the worst possible consequence. If the allegations are proved, inaccurate records would have impaired oversight during an already urgent inquiry. If they are not proved, the officers' denials must carry their full weight. The hearing is expected to continue until the end of the week, with a finding and any disciplinary outcome still to follow.

Sources

Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-16