Skip to content
wua. United Kingdom English

Alan Milburn youth jobs report: Employer NI cuts could lower hiring barriers, but they are not a jobs plan yet

AI-generated editorial illustration; this is not a photograph of the event.
Produced by wua.life

Alan Milburn’s proposed employer National Insurance cut for 21-to-24-year-olds identifies a real weakness in youth-employment policy: support for jobseekers cannot substitute for employers offering entry-level jobs. But it remains a recommendation, not a funded hiring programme, and ministers should not present it as one.

The former Labour minister’s youth-unemployment review is due on Tuesday. The BBC reports that it will propose gradually reducing employer NI costs over five years for workers aged 21 to 24, beginning in retail and hospitality. Milburn is also expected to recommend raising the earnings threshold at which employers begin paying NI for that group from £5,000 to £10,000, but only when fiscal conditions allow.

The emphasis on those sectors is understandable. The BBC says retail and hospitality account for 37% of jobs held by 16-to-24-year-olds. Lowering the cost of taking on a young worker could matter where employers are weighing up an apprentice, a junior role or fewer staff. It addresses the demand side of youth employment more directly than telling young people to become more job-ready.

The government has separately announced earlier access to its subsidised jobs guarantee for 18-to-24-year-olds claiming Universal Credit. Eligible people will qualify after 12 months on benefits rather than 18 months, and the scheme guarantees a six-month job. That is a useful change in timing, but it is different from Milburn’s proposed tax measure: one subsidises a defined placement after a period on benefits, while the other is intended to alter employers’ ongoing recruitment costs.

The strongest counterargument is fiscal. The Resolution Foundation estimates that immediately removing employer NI for 21-to-24-year-olds would cost £5.1bn, according to the BBC. Milburn therefore argues that an immediate, universal cut would not be the best use of public money. That caution is warranted. The available reporting does not show how the gradual reduction would be funded, its final sector rules, or how many additional jobs it would create.

The sensible test is straightforward. Ministers should assess whether a targeted NI change produces genuinely additional entry-level hiring alongside the expanded jobs guarantee. Reducing pressure on benefit claimants without securing real vacancies would merely move the problem; lowering employer costs without a credible fiscal plan would do little better.

Sources

Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-16

Alan Milburn opportunity guarantee: A legal route into work needs support before benefit cuts