
The reported restriction on Professor Peter Hindmarsh’s clinical practice does not itself overturn Lucy Letby’s convictions. It does, however, create a specific and serious question about whether the defence had the information needed to test a key prosecution expert’s credibility.
The Guardian reports that University College London Hospitals excluded Hindmarsh from clinical practice in March 2023, five months before the Letby trial ended. The paper says the trust raised concerns over the risk it believed he posed to children and young people, including in advice involving insulin. Hindmarsh had been a central prosecution witness on the allegation that insulin was introduced into intravenous fluid bags.
According to the report, Letby’s legal team was not told that UCLH had stopped him practising, or of an April 2023 medical practitioners tribunal decision requiring direct supervision. The jury was also not told. Those are reported procedural facts, not a judicial finding that anyone breached disclosure rules or that Hindmarsh’s trial evidence was false.
That distinction matters. A clinical restriction is not automatically a finding that an expert’s evidence in an earlier criminal case was unreliable. The tribunal did not suspend Hindmarsh’s registration, and the Court of Appeal has already rejected Letby’s applications to appeal. Hindmarsh did not answer the Guardian’s questions.
But the counterargument does not remove the disclosure issue. A witness presented by the prosecution as a leading insulin specialist was reportedly subject to serious, later restrictions relating to professional judgment and patient safety while the trial was still under way. If the defence did not receive that information, it could have affected the questions it chose to ask, whether it sought to challenge his standing, and whether it asked the judge to consider the evidence differently.
Letby’s lawyer has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission. The commission, rather than public debate, will have to assess any material placed before it under its statutory test. The immediate lesson from this disclosure is narrower but important: expert authority must be open to meaningful challenge, especially where it bears on a criminal case of this gravity.
Sources
- The Guardian · UK · Source date: 2026-11-18
Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-18