
Two Barcelona courts have reached opposite conclusions on the Govern’s ban on remote work for subdirectors general. The clash turns an internal workplace rule into a legal question with wider administrative significance: how far can a government go in requiring in-person work from a defined group of senior civil servants?
elDiario.es reported on 17 November that one judge annulled the ban while another judge had upheld it. The ruling that supported the Govern’s position relied on a consequential distinction: remote work was not an employee right, but a way of delivering public services. That view supports the administration’s ability to organise how certain posts are performed. It does not, by itself, settle whether this specific restriction meets the legal requirements that apply to these senior roles.
The disagreement is expected to go before the administrative chamber of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC), which is to unify the criterion. Its central task will not be to decide whether remote work is generally good or bad. It will be to define the Govern’s legal room to restrict it for senior posts and the justification required for doing so.
The case for the ban cannot simply be dismissed. Public administrations need authority to organise services and, where responsibilities require it, to set attendance conditions. Yet the incompatible first-instance rulings are also a reason for caution: they show that the legal basis for this targeted restriction cannot be treated as settled.
The TSJC’s future ruling should establish the applicable standard. Until then, treating either Barcelona decision as the final answer would flatten a dispute that has plainly reached a higher judicial stage.
Sources
- elDiario.es · Source date: 2026-11-17
Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-18