
Prosecutors learned that the General Medical Council was investigating Professor Peter Hindmarsh shortly before he gave evidence for a second time at Lucy Letby’s trial in February 2023, the BBC reported on 19 November. The Crown Prosecution Service says it met all its disclosure obligations and that the investigation itself did not determine whether his evidence was admissible or reliable.
Hindmarsh, a specialist in paediatric endocrinology, had been referred to the regulator before his first appearance at Manchester Crown Court in November 2022. On that occasion he gave his opinion on the prolonged low blood sugar of a baby known as Child F. When he returned in February, he told the court that, in his view, insulin poisoning was the only reasonable explanation for a second baby’s blood readings.
Telling the defence about the investigation and putting it before the jury were separate steps. According to the Guardian’s account, cited by the BBC, prosecutors told Letby’s lawyers they would oppose raising the matter with jurors because the regulator had not reached a conclusion. The defence did not apply to put it before the jury. The CPS says the defence raised no objection to the expert evidence.
The Guardian reports that the hospital excluded Hindmarsh from clinical practice over safety concerns in March 2023. That decision came after his February testimony: what prosecutors knew when he returned to court concerned the investigation, not the subsequent restriction. Following reporting on the restriction, Letby’s lawyer has called on the Court of Appeal to review her convictions urgently.
Sources
- BBC UK · Source date: 2026-11-19
- The Guardian · UK · Source date: 2026-11-19
Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-20