
Three chambers of Poland’s Supreme Court held on 18 November that a Constitutional Tribunal judgment binds everyone even if it has not appeared in the official journal. According to Polsat News, the chambers also set out a condition for a ruling to count as a Tribunal judgment: every member of the panel must have taken the oath in the president’s presence after being elected by the Sejm, Poland’s lower house of parliament.
Joanna Misztal-Konecka, president of the Civil Chamber, had submitted three questions, including one about the force of Tribunal judgments left unpublished over the past two years. The Civil Chamber, the Labour and Social Insurance Chamber and the Chamber of Extraordinary Review and Public Affairs adopted the resolution on Wednesday afternoon after meeting throughout the day.
In explaining the resolution, Judge Aleksander Stępkowski addressed what the president’s presence at the oath might mean. He said he could envisage the president attending remotely in extraordinary circumstances.
For someone relying on an unpublished ruling, the panel comes first: who sat on it, and did each member meet the oath requirement? Once a ruling qualifies as a Tribunal judgment, its absence from the official journal does not strip it of binding force. That distinction rules out treating all the unpublished decisions from the past two years alike solely because none appeared in the journal.
Sources
- Polsat News · Source date: 2026-11-18
Independent editorial content. WUA is not affiliated with any political party. 2026-11-18